Dustin Question:A friend of mine brought a homemade pumpkin pie to our Thanksgiving dinner this evening, and it had a unappealing gray/green tinge to it. It smelled alright. I did not take a bite, but the other guests said it tasted fine. I just couldn't bring myself to try it. Of course, I whipped out my cookbooks, food chemistry books, and looked Online to see what I could find, but was unsuccessful. Do you have any idea what could have caused this? Thank you! Respectfully Rose Reply: this is a stretch but since this happened to me over 40 years ago i'll share this story/explanation: i was making an angel pie from the old joy of cooking and when i got to the part where it said: ïf you need to know more about egg cookery see page..." i ignored this and used my aluminum saucepan to cook the egg yolk mixture which turned a sort of chartreuse which sounds a bit like the pumpkin pie in question. most people don't have aluminum pans anymore so books don't even warn you about this, but maybe the pumpkin pie filling was mixed in an aluminum pan. find out and get back to us. maybe someone else will have another suggestion as to possible cause! but had i turned to the page suggested i would have read that egg yolk reacts to aluminum causing it to turn an unsightly color. it is for this reason that i put warnings in the cake bible right on the page where the recipe is written so that it can't be ignored!
Guidelines for Posting a Comment
Post your comment by clicking on Comment. If you have a question, please post it on Ask A Question. If you feel one of our recipes is incorrect, please look for the recipe on our Blog Categories: BOOK CORRECTIONS to see if there has been a posted revision. (You can also copy and print off any of the pages to include with your books.)
Please do not have: your name as a portal-link to a website, website links, or your email address included with your comments, or we will repost your comment with out any links. Also, please post your comment here, versus trying to email us privately, or we will reply by asking you to post here.